Despite a packed crowd on Coal Rush night, West Virginia (2-6, 0-5) fell short against TCU, losing 23-17. Read more: Coal Rush Not Enough: West Virginia Falls 23-17
While the defense looked strong at times, the offense continued its season struggles. Third and fourth down inefficiencies played a key role in the offense’s lack of consistent success on Saturday night.
A Slow Start
With Scotty Fox Jr. starting for the injured Khalil Wilkins, the Mountaineers received the ball to start the game. After garnering zero yards in three plays, punter Oliver Straw kicked his first punt of the day.
The Horned Frogs started hot with a 26-yard completion from quarterback Josh Hoover to receiver Major Everhart. After an incompletion and two short completions, TCU was forced to kick a 35-yard field goal, which they converted.
Once West Virginia got the ball back, they found themselves in a fourth and short. Fox attempted to get it himself, however was stopped short by TCU’s stingy defensive line.
TCU gave the ball back to WVU after a zero-yard rush and back-to-back incompletions.
The Mountaineers once again punted after a three-and-out.
TCU started with good field position after Straw managed just a 19-yard punt. After a failed rush attempt on first-and-10, the Horned Frogs converted three straight first downs.
Just a few short plays later, running back Trent Battle got TCU its first touchdown of the game after a one-yard rushing touchdown.
A Promising 2nd Quarter?
To open the second quarter, the Mountaineers were marching in what looked to be their best drive of the game.
Fox and the offense once again found themselves in a fourth down to start, where this time Fox would convert with his legs. He then found tight end Ryan Ward for a 16-yard completion.
A trio of five-plus runs found West Virginia on TCU’s 30-yard line. However, they found themselves in another fourth down, where running back Diore Hubbard could not convert.
The Mountaineer defense looked to pick up some of the slack as Devin sacked Hoover on first down. The Horned Frogs were forced to punt two plays later.
After a botched punt, West Virginia received the ball at TCU’s 35-yard line. On second-and-13, Fox located Jarod Bowie for a 15-yard completion.
Related: Jen Greeny on Growth, Grit, and Building WVU Volleyball’s Foundation
After Cyncir Bowers recovered his own fumble, the very next play, Fox found tight end Grayson Barnes for a 17-yard touchdown.
In response, TCU began to roll after a pass interference call on third down. A few plays later, they converted their own fourth down.
Hoover followed that up with an 11-yard and 18-yard completion. The Horned Frogs got down to the Mountaineers’ four-yard line, where Hoover found Eric McAlister for his second touchdown of the game.
Once WVU got the ball back, they found themselves quickly in another third down. Fox found Hubbard for a first down.
After a pass inference call on TCU, the Mountaineers once again were faced with a fourth down. Once again, Fox could not convert it with his legs.
On the ensuing play, Battle found a hole and rushed for 46 yards, finally getting tackled at WVU’s 12-yard line. After a Battle zero-yard rush and two incompletions, the Horned Frogs converted on a 22-yard field goal.
After the Mountaineers opted to run out the clock, they went into the half down 20-7.
A Dull Third Quarter
To open up the second half, TCU got moving quickly with an 11-yard pass on third down. Hoover converted a 21-yard completion immediately after, but three plays later, they were forced to punt.
Despite a 16-yard and 12-yard completion from Fox, the Mountaineers were also halted on their promising drive. They were forced to punt on TCU’s 42-yard line.
The Horned Frogs looked to find some offensive rhythm as Hoover completed a 28-yard pass to McAlister on the second play of the drive. After an incompletion, Battle had another strong run, rushing for 12 yards.
A couple of plays later, TCU failed to convert on a fourth down.
Fox and the offense started to get the passing game figured out. He rattled off three straight completions to help get the Mountaineers to TCU’s 38-yard line.
After a 29-yard completion to Cam Vaughn, the Mountaineers were forced to settle for a 28-yard field goal after Fox was sacked on third and goal.
A Disappointing End
Going into the final quarter, the Horned Frogs were rolling after a 14-yard completion on second down.
However, after an incompletion to start the fourth, they were forced to punt.
Starting at their own 14-yard line, running back Clay Ash ran for 10 yards on the first play. Following that, Fox completed a 22-yard catch to Jeff Weimer.
After a pass interference call a few plays later, WVU failed to convert after an incompletion on fourth down.
Following that, the Horned Frogs managed to put together a 13-play drive that spanned almost seven minutes of game time. It resulted in a 41-yard field goal.
Related: Utah Defeats WVU at Homecoming Matchup in Five Sets
Down 23-10, the Mountaineers had to put together something quick. Fox completed back-to-back passes to get a first down.
Then an 18-yard completion to Bowie put them at TCU’s 44-yard line. Three plays later, Fox threw it right in Weimer’s hands for a 28-yard touchdown pass.
West Virginia attempted an onside kick, where they were inches away from falling on it.
A few plays later, Hoover once again found McAlister for a first down, ultimately ending the game.
The Horned Frogs ran out the rest of the clock, finishing the game 23-17.
Strides were Made
While West Virginia did lose its fifth game in a row, it showed some positive signs of growth.
While inconsistent, the offense had 342 total yards, one less than TCU. In particular, the passing game was much better as Scotty Fox Jr. threw for 301 yards and two touchdowns.
The defense also played well at times. The biggest issue being too many chunk plays given up.
West Virginia will look to bounce back and get back in the win column on November 1, where they will take on Houston.

Definite improvement in many areas. Game was a lot closer than the score. Looks to me like they are figuring things out a bit. I bet we get another W before the season ends.