Menu Close

Which College Football Playoff Model Benefits West Virginia Most?

While the Big 12 media days saw Rich Rodriguez take responsibility for his past and Scott Frost shirk it, the SEC went in a different direction.

Their battle was over the future of the playoff and how it’s going to impact the sport.

The playoff is here to stay; we’re not going back to fewer than 12 teams. But the big question is the format. Will we stick with the current 12 teams, go to 16 with automatic bids for champions only, or go to 16 with automatic bids beyond conference champions?

There are reasons for each model, which is why there’s such a debate between the SEC and the Big Ten and the SEC vs. itself. But from a West Virginia perspective, here’s how each college football playoff model would affect the Mountaineers.

Read More: Which College Football Playoff Model Benefits West Virginia Most?

Playoffs Are a Long-Term Goal for West Virginia

Let’s get this out of the way: West Virginia probably isn’t making the playoffs in 2025. The program has gotten to the level where it can dream before, and it can again. But this is not an overnight fix. If Rich Rodriguez is thinking about playoff formats this year, something unexpected has gone well.

The playoffs would be more realistic in 2027 or 2028, after Rodriguez has had time to get his guys throughout the program. By then, we might have a totally different format.

Related: Wetherholt Promoted to Memphis

The big question, then, is how things would look moving forward. For West Virginia, the biggest things to consider are access to the playoff and whether they could get a game in Morgantown. And there’s one model that checks both of those boxes.

A College Football Playoff Model Of 16 Expands Hosting Options

Right now, a top-four finish is desirable, but comes with a problem of not getting a home game. We saw last year that all four teams who got a home game in round 1 made the semifinals, along with getting revenue pouring in from an extra game.

Again, West Virginia doesn’t have to worry about a home game until it’s in the mix to win the Big 12. But it’s important to think about. The Mountaineers want to be in that conversation, and Wren Baker and the athletic department need to be mindful about what things will look like if and when they get there.

Related: JJ Quinerly Earns Player of Game for Wings

The automatic bye is no longer a thing after all five conference champions got picked off in their first game. This also had a lot to do with the failure of the bracket. That makes 2025 a pivotal year for deciding how many teams will participate. If the top four teams again struggle after a long layoff, that’s probably the end of the 12-team model. If they perform better this time around, the 12-team model becomes viable.

Obviously, the Mountaineers have a better chance to qualify with four more spots available. When Rodriguez last coached West Virginia, his final three teams would have been in the mix for the playoff. However, the 2007 team is the only one that would have absolutely gotten in under the 12-team model. 2005 would have either been the last team in or the last team out, and 2006 would have needed the extra four slots.

So the Mountaineers should probably root for the expansion to 16 for their long-term future.

What Are the Two 16-Team Suggestions?

Unsurprisingly, the SEC and the Big Ten each favor a model that benefits their own league most. The SEC favors automatic bids for the five highest-ranked conference champions, with 11 at-large bids decided by committee. SEC commissioner Greg Sankey has suggested that the league could adopt another model, but for now, it seems mostly committed to this format.

The Big Ten has chosen to go another direction. Currently, the Big Ten favors a model that locks in 14 bids for the top four conferences. This would give the SEC and Big Ten four bids each, with three each going to the ACC and Big 12. The last two spots would include one at-large bid, plus one for the best Group of 6 champion.

Related: Looking at Conference Opponent Utah

At first glance, that might seem better for West Virginia. But giving the SEC and Big Ten that much power could be devastating. First, in a balanced league like the Big 12, getting one of those three automatic bids out of 16 would be difficult. Second, there’s no way the Big 12 would really be treated fairly. It would play second fiddle to the SEC and Big Ten, and while the SEC has earned that, the Big Ten has not.

Third, this model would hurt a school like West Virginia that intentionally schedules tough games. If all bids but one were tied to a conference, playing the likes of Pitt and Penn State wouldn’t do anything to help the Mountaineers’ playoff chances. They’d be giving themselves a tougher strength of schedule with little benefit to their long-term prospects.

Conversely, a school like Indiana would benefit from playing a softer schedule. The Hoosiers have been in the news for the wrong reasons lately, as they’ve canceled a series with Virginia to play Group of 6 opponents. Under the Big Ten’s college football playoff model, canceling games with Power 4 opponents could become the norm. That’s not West Virginia’s style, and it could cost the Mountaineers in that scenario.

What Should Mountaineer Fans Hope For?

Honestly, the best college football playoff model for the Mountaineers is either the status quo or the SEC model. If West Virginia doesn’t make the playoff this year, the best outcome for the Mountaineers is for the SEC’s model to prevail. It’s the best option for maximizing access to the playoff and potential home games.

Failing that, keeping the 12-team model viable would be a good consolation prize. The current model isn’t bad; it’s just not as good as it could be. West Virginia would have to work a little harder to qualify, but it can do it.

Either way, the biggest concern for the Mountaineers is to get to where this conversation matters. If Rich Rodriguez can make the college football playoff model a concern for the Blue and Gold, everyone in the state would be thrilled.

Author

  • Dan Angell, Staff Writer

    Dan Angell has been a sportswriter for the past 20 years and has covered events such as the NCAA tournament, the Maui Invitational, the NFL scouting combine and the Big Ten tournament. He has focused mostly on analysis and why things turn out the way they do on game day, and he believes strongly in trusting his information and understanding to reach the right conclusion.

    View all posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *